Are the good times
All year long, we've
been hearing that the housing rebound is upon us. Yes, there has been some
marked cooling in the market in the past couple of months, but by and large,
the stars have remained aligned.
The economy is
recovering, unemployment is inching down and the Federal Reserve is trying to
keep interest rates low, helping create the greatest buyers' market in anyone's
memory. Things are looking brighter for sellers, too. The often-quoted
S&P/Case-Shiller home-price index is chronicling the biggest price
increases in half a decade.
Secrets to Selling (Or
Buying) a House Today
It no doubt makes a
lot of people want to jump into the housing market again.
And perhaps they
We're also hearing the
siren song that led so many buyers astray during the bubble: that real estate
is a great way to build wealth and financial security. And we're seeing home
buyers, like retail stock investors rushing after a hot IPO, moving into a
housing market that has already been plowed through by institutional and
So, don't let the
euphoria over a recovery obscure the market's flashing yellow lights. Like all
economic booms, this one carries the instruments of its own destruction.
With that in mind,
here are five of those yellow lights to keep in mind before you decide how much
to bid on that house‚ÄĒor whether to bid at all.
1. This recovery leaves a
lot to be desired.
Yes, housing has
certainly turned a corner. All in all, home-sales volume is about where it was
in 1999, while inflation-adjusted prices are at 2000-2001 levels. In July, the
National Association of Realtors clocked existing-home sales at an annual rate of
about 5.39 million‚ÄĒup 17% from a year earlier.
Construction is up,
too. According to the Census Bureau, building permits for single-family homes
were issued in July at an annual rate of 613,000, up from the post-bubble nadir
of 337,000 in January 2009.
But the current
figures don't come anywhere close to the recent highs. Existing-home sales are
up, but they're still about 27% below the figure from mid-2005. And those
613,000 building permits hardly compare to the bubble-era high of 1,798,000 in
So, the best you can
say right now is housing has leveled out after a 13-year roller-coaster ride
that has seen massive government and Federal Reserve efforts to spur demand. Is
that a recovery?
2. The new boom is a
rehash of the old one.
A look at a map
quickly shows where the current action is. The West and parts of the South are
hot. Most of the Middle West and Northeast are lukewarm.
And if that sounds
familiar, it is. Most of today's boom is happening where Bubble 1.0 swelled and
burst midway through the last decade: Florida, Phoenix, Las Vegas and
California's Central Valley. Indeed, of the 20 hottest markets of 2013, 17 are
west of the Rockies‚ÄĒ12 in California.
So, a lot of the
impressive percentage gains in price we're seeing lately are coming from very
low levels. In hard-hit Bakersfield, Calif., for example, prices fell nearly
54% from their bubble-era zenith in 2006 to their nadir in 2011, according to
the Home Price Index of the Federal Housing Finance Agency. So, the 14% bump
from 2012 to 2013 is an improvement and no doubt heartening to existing
homeowners who have seen median prices rise to $188,000. But, like the old song
goes, it's more a case of "down so long it looks like up to me" than
a genuine recovery.
The stories are
similar in other bubble-scarred areas. But in places like Kansas City,
Pittsburgh or St. Louis that barely experienced Bubble 1.0, today's market is
not nearly so robust.
Even when there are
impressive-looking percentage gains outside of the old boomtowns, there's
usually a deeper story at work. Consider this sobering stat: In the
battle-scarred city of Detroit, prices in July were up 33% over a year ago.
Detroit's new median
selling price? $13,556.
3. Big businesses are
doing a lot of buying.
Two of the most
troubling aspects of the housing recovery, so far, have related to the outsize
presence of deep-pocketed Wall Street investors acting out a monumental episode
of "Flip This House."
Their presence is
driving price increases and sales volume even as they frequently outbid
individual home buyers. Indeed, it's a great paradox that the new real-estate
boom is taking place alongside a plunging rate of homeownership. The
homeownership rate‚ÄĒthe percentage of housing units occupied by their owners‚ÄĒhas
fallen from a bubble-era high of 69.2% to today's 65%, the lowest level since
1995. (A four-percentage-point falloff is huge. The rate has been above 60%
since the 1950s.)
These corporate cash
buyers have spent much of the past three years stoking local real-estate
markets by bulk buying tens of thousands of troubled single-family homes,
fixing them up and renting them, focusing on the metro areas with the greatest
number of distressed properties. Frequently, the new renters are just the kinds
of families who might have been buyers of those very houses 10 years ago but
are now unable to meet today's more stringent mortgage-loan requirements.
In 2012, institutional
buyers purchased about 140,000 homes in the U.S., or about 3% of all sales,
according to RealtyTrac, a real-estate data firm in Irvine, Calif., but that
tiny percentage obscures the impact of corporate buyers in individual markets.
In July, institutional investors accounted for 25% of home purchases in
metropolitan Atlanta and 20% in Tampa.
Of course, fixing up
houses and renting them out is an old mom-and-pop business. But the volume of
today's institutional purchases is quite unlike anything individual investors
could ever pull off. And, just as Joe and Jane Home Buyers are awakening to the
renewed vitality of the housing market, some of Wall Street's smart money seems
to think real estate is already peaking or at least that the easy money has
already been made.
The companies' early
investors are pocketing their double-digit gains and are now liquidating their
investment positions by selling shares in their companies to the public on the
stock market. American Homes 4 Rent, a real-estate investment trust formed in 2011,
has bought, renovated and now rents out about 18,000 homes in 21 states,
focusing on California, Arizona and Florida. The company's shares went public
on Aug. 1 in a $705.9 million IPO. It was the third such company to go public
Wall Street's No. 1
U.S. house owner is Invitation Homes, a unit of Blackstone GroupBX -2.01% LP. In less than two
years, Blackstone has amassed a collection of about 30,000 houses‚ÄĒmost in
hard-hit real-estate markets such as Tampa, Orlando, California's Inland
Empire, Las Vegas and Phoenix. Blackstone, which describes its real-estate
philosophy as "buy it, fix it, sell it," is already preparing IPOs
for its other commercial real-estate holdings.
4. Investing in housing
is nothing like buying a home.
A market that's good
for investors may not be so hot for you.
No doubt, the
corporate buyers have created a great business. But few individual home buyers,
lured by the headlines of a new real-estate boom, understand that the
house-owning math of investors is 180 degrees from the rest of us who are
buying a place to live in.
And don't forget:
You're bidding against these buyers, and the odds are stacked against you.
Your home isn't an
investment property. Investment properties have cash flow and pay for
themselves. Homes don't; homeowners pay for them.
investors usually buy with cash. Their acquisition and maintenance expenses are
paid by rental income, and they're taxed on only the difference between their
revenue and expenses. There are other real-estate tax advantages, including
depreciation, that enhance cash flow but are unavailable to individuals. Losses
can be carried over year after year and used to offset profits elsewhere. And
real-estate investors have a leg up even on stock investors because they can
avoid capital-gains taxes completely if they sell and buy "in kind"
investors don't live in their portfolios, so they can buy and sell without
incurring the inconveniences of moving and committing their sale proceeds to
contrast, usually borrow money, which means that, even at today's ultralow
interest rates, the cost of a home over the 30-year life of a mortgage will be
70% or more above the purchase price. On top of that, homeowners must cover
their maintenance costs with after-tax income.
mortgage-interest tax deduction is of little value to owners outside the most
expensive communities because the annual interest payment on a typical home
loan is not significantly different from the standard deduction available to
all taxpayers. The home sellers' $500,000 ($250,000 for individuals)
capital-gains exclusion is irrelevant for most homeowners, since few home sales
produce actual profits. (That's right. No profit. You have most likely paid far
more in interest, taxes, maintenance, improvements and other home-owning
expenses than the difference between your purchase and selling prices.)
5. Interest rates are on
The great house
buyers' market is still on. And it's likely to keep going as long as the
economy can create jobs that pay well enough to buy (or rent) at today's
prices. That is especially good news for home sellers, many of whom have been
locked in their homes for years, unable to sell and move up or on.
But as the economic
recovery has slowly gained momentum, interest rates have begun to rise. At some
point, they will rise to levels that eliminate today's home-buying advantages.
New-home prices have already reached their nominal bubble-era highs, and
existing-home prices are not far behind.
As interest rates rise
to their traditional levels, generally between 5% and 7%, you can expect either
prices to stabilize or sales volumes to decline. Ominously, the Mortgage
Bankers Association this month noted a decline of more than 70% in
refinance-loan applications since rates began rising in May and about a 15%
falloff of purchase-loan applications.
That said, mortgage
money is still a remarkable bargain. Today's 30-year fixed rates are still far
cheaper than in 40 of the past 42 years. Even today's more elevated rates
(4.57% as of last week)‚ÄĒmore than a percentage point higher than in January‚ÄĒare
less than the average rate for all of 2010.
Two years ago, like
today, no one believed rates could fall further. Indeed, the warnings were that
rates were bound to rise. And then, like today, it was a great time to buy a
(By: David Crook -
Author:Joshua Smith Phone: 623-703-7445 Dated: January 24th 2014 Views: 3,113 About Joshua: ...
View our latest blog posts in your RSS reader. Click here to access.
We are a full service real estate team that believes in delivering world class service to our clients. We will do everything possible to ensure our clients real estate goals are met. Joshua Smith Real Estate Group has been rated the 30th top Real Estate Team in America by The Wall Street Journal and the only way to achieve this type of success is by providing extraordinary service to our clients. We look forward to helping you and your family accomplish your real estate goals!